Local Knowledge.

Real Coverage.

Service You Can Trust.

When you live or work in the Hudson Valley, you want insurance that fits your life-without the runaround. That's where we come in. From renters & homeowners to contractors & small businesses, we help you protect what matters most with affordable, reliable insurance solutions you can count on year after year.

A black and white drawing of a shield with a person 's face inside of it.

Personal Insurance

A black and white icon of a building in a shield.

Commercial Insurance

Personal & Commercial Insurance with a Local Touch

Trusted New York State Insurance Agency for Personal & Commercial Coverage

When you live or work in New York, you want insurance that fits your life-without the runaround. That's where we come in. From renters & homeowners to contractors & small businesses, we help you protect what matters most with affordable, reliable insurance solutions you can count on year after year.

What We Offer

Explore Coverage Options That Fit Your Needs

A family is sitting at a table looking at a laptop computer.

Personal Insurance

Home, auto, renters, landlords, umbrella & more



Explore Commercial Insurance
A delivery man is giving a package to a woman in front of a van.

Commercial Insurance

Reach out to us or request a personalized quote



Explore Life Insurance
A man in an apron is serving a woman in a cafe.

Bonds

Surety & license bonds for business owners and professionals



Explore Commercial Insurance
A man and a woman are sitting at a table looking at a laptop.

A Selection of Trusted Carriers We Work With

Local Service You Can Count On

Why Choose a New York State Insurance Team

We know the risks around here

From frozen pipes in Mahopac to car accidents on Route 6, we're familiar with the issues that impact homes & businesses in this part of New York.

Fast, real help when you need it

No long phone trees or call centers. When you need to talk to someone, we're right here in Baldwin Place ready to help.

Independent means more choices

We're not tied to one carrier. That means we can shop around to find the policy that works best for your needs & budget.

Trusted by your neighbors

We've built lasting relationships with families & businesses across the Southern Hudson Valley. Most of our new clients come from referrals.

Our Carriers

What Our Clients Say

Real Feedback from Local Clients

A woman in a blue jacket and white shirt is smiling
A man in a light blue shirt is standing in front of a window with his arms crossed.
A woman in a black jacket and white ruffled blouse smiles for the camera

"I've used this agency for years-they're quick, honest, and truly care. When a pipe burst in my basement, they helped me file my claim and got things moving fast."

- Danielle R., Mahopac, NY

"I run a small construction business and needed general liability and commercial auto coverage. They made the process so easy."

- Mike G., Yorktown Heights

So easy to work with...always accessible via phone or email. Very professional and pleasant.

- Fortune A.

Honest. Dependable. Professional. Friendly. Affordable. Current. This agency has it all. Will never bring my insurance needs anywhere else. Peter and his staff are first class. You won't be disappointed!

- Bettina P.

Pleasant, efficient and competitive pricing.

-Tami P.

Had no issues. Everything moved quickly. Saved a bunch of money.

- Ron R.

The Valhalla Agency has been my insurance broker for the past 35 years; as always, our experience with Pete and his staff is phenomenal! They answer my questions quickly and curiously; no matter how many times I ask the question! They make themselves available whenever you need them. They work hard for their customers, and I wouldn’t have anyone else take care of my insurance needs!

- Irene C.

I've worked with Peter and his staff for years. They have always been professional, prompt and courteous. They sorted out whatever was needed every time. I would highly recommend working with them.

- James S.

Great communication and honesty

- Joe V.

It’s a pleasure working with Pete. Always provides prompt, professional service and always responds in a timely manner and values my business both personally and professionally.


- Theresa

Everything was completed quickly and easily.

- Phil A.

Peter is always the best!! We appreciate your help always

- Dynamic I.

I use Valhalla agency for all my car and home needs. They are knowledgeable, always available ,and fair with pricing. I would highly recommend.

- Deirdre P.

The best customer service and professional support!! I wouldn’t go anywhere else!!

- Nanette R.

Valhalla Agency is very accessible, responsive and professional.

- Sven H.

Very professional with a great customer experience

- Gary A.

Quick. Efficient. Honest. Price-efficient. These are the qualities Pete Cuomo brings to the table, and the reason why I would recommend him to anyone who is looking to potentially lower their annual insurance premiums.

- A. C.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What types of insurance do you offer?

    We offer a wide range of personal and commercial policies-everything from home and auto insurance to cyber liability and surety bonds. We'll walk you through your options clearly.

  • How do I get a quote?

    Click "Get a Quote" anywhere on the site or give us a call. We'll ask a few quick questions and get quotes from top carriers so you can compare options side by side.

  • Do I have to come into the office?

    Not at all. We're happy to work with you by phone, text, or email. If you'd like to come in, we can schedule a time that works best for you.

  • Can you help with claims?

    Yes. If you ever need to file a claim, we're here to walk you through the process. We can help you understand your coverage, gather what's needed, and follow up if things stall.

Insurance Tips, Local Insights & More

Overlooked Home Insurance Riders: Are You Missing Important Coverage?

Teen Driving Awareness: Celebrating Milestones and Prioritizing Safety

Protecting Your Holiday Treasures: Insurance Tips

Spooky Truths About Life Insurance Gaps

Umbrella Insurance: The Affordable Coverage Most People Overlook

How New York’s No-Fault Auto Insurance Laws Affect You

What First-Time Homebuyers in New York Should Know About Home Insurance
Get Started

Let's Make Insurance Easy

Not sure what kind of coverage you need? Just ask. We're happy to walk through your options and help you make the right decision. Whether it's a quote for your home, your car, or your company, we make it simple to get covered.